I read a book recently, titled, “Comfortably Numb: How psychiatry is medicating a nation,” by Charles Barber, a lecturer in psychiatry at the Yale University School of Medicine. Barber contends that Americans are horrendously overdosed in psychiatric medicines, and provides facts and stories to back up his case.
Some quotes from his book:
“In 2006, 227 million antidepressant prescriptions were dispensed to Americans—more than any other class of medication—and up by 30 million prescriptions since 2002.”
“Americans are responsible for almost half of the world’s prescription drug sales….In 2006, Americans—about 6 percent of the world’s population—bought about two-thirds of the world’s psychiatric and neurological drugs. In 2006, 66 percent of the global antidepressant market was accounted for by the United States.”
“To say that we are the most medicated nation on earth is an absurd understatement. To say that we are the most psychiatrically medicated nation on earth is a prodigiously absurd understatement.”
Barber is not arguing that the medicines should be done away with, but that Americans are putting too much faith in them. He gives examples of how advertising campaigns lull consumers into believing doses of these drugs are healthy for them, when quite the opposite is true. He also contends that Americans are sanitizing themselves with drugs to avoid dealing with the highs and lows of human experience. They are practicing a form of escapism rather than working life’s problems out constructively.
He wrote:
“It has been widely observed that the SSRIs [form of antidepressant drug] put many people at a sort of remove from reality, a distance from the self. I’ve seen SSRIs block out both the good and the bad, numbing us to the pandemonium of life….The emotional highs and lows are excised from experience, and one exists in a slightly foggy middle ground….They function; they don’t get too excited or too upset. They get by. They come to inhabit an inauthentic and less challenging existence and embrace a uniquely American form of emotional sanitation.”
This last observation is what I have noted in people on antidepressant drugs. They are not themselves anymore. They are drugged into a state of semi-individuality that loses touch with reality.
Of course, there is a need to help people out of depressive states of mind that cause them to struggle, and healing is possible through prayer and spiritual treatment of thought. There is one Mind, and it’s a happy healthy Mind which everyone is divinely designed to express.
Heavy and dark states of mortal mind may seem to weigh that joy down for a spell in the human mind, but it cannot endure. Christ is ever-present in human consciousness helping each individual find the light that brings genuine joy back into their experience.
Barber still advocates medicine for severe depression, mostly because he knows no other way to cope with it. He’s willing to compromise on the tough cases. But for the most part, he encourages his readers to deal with life’s realities rather than trying to avoid them through drugging.
Amen!
Americans are way too overmedicated. Books like this help snap lulled consumers out of complacency and acquiescence to ever-increasing doses of medicine that do great harm and avoid dealing with the real issues of life through logic, reason and spirituality.
Everyone has a right to live an authentic life! But it won’t be found in a drugged-up state of mind. It’s found through spiritual growth, increased spirituality and consecrated prayer.
Even worse is prescribing medication for our youth, including the very young. 15 years ago I went to the high school for a conference with my son’s teachers, one of whom suggested he should be medicated for depression. I was quietly upset about this, and in privacy the counselor asked me why. I told her that as a student of Christian Science I did not believe medication would solve my son’s problem. She said that the decision was mine, adding that there were too many students walking the halls “like zombies.” Well, I’m just so grateful I know something of the way to pray about the drug issue through my study of Christian Science.
WOW! Well said. Before I came into Christian Science 8 years ago, I spent many years in AA. By the early 1990’s, it had become difficult to “sponsor” or mentor new people because most of them had been put on antidepressants. It seems that addiction is now treated as a prescription drug deficiency! I noticed that, rather than working through the pain and loss of a normal sobering up process, they took the drugs doctors had prescribed to make the recovery easier. The people were robbed of an authentic recovery and of the joy that goes with it. Thanks Evan for a great reminder. I should also mention that I have a degree in pharmacy from the 1970’s, and there were VERY few people on psychotropic drugs at the time. The speed of the change is shocking.
if you are 60 or older… fully 85% take some form of medication for a degenerative disease, such as diabetes, heart, etc.
and the average American takes between 6 and 8 medications. Some to offset the effects of the first. Indeed, we are in the minority when we look to Divine help as our comfort and strength.
Woodrow
Two nights ago on the national news it was announced that there was now a push on to have every high school student in the US go through a mandatory screening for depression before they could attend school.
You know what follows mandatory screenings…
Oops! It said the govt panel was recommending screening for all teenager students but not that it was required for student attendance in school. Sorry I mis- spoke.
“There is one Mind, and it’s a happy healthy Mind which everyone is divinely designed to express.” What a fresh way to put it!
May I cross-reference the article I mentioned on your children overmedicated blog here: http://www.wildestcolts.com/john/clay.html.
Did anyone see Jenny McCarthy and her son, along with Jim Carrey (sp?), on Larry King Live last week? The stance taken by the pediatric association rep revealed
the medical world’s dependence on drugs, including immunizations given to infants to ward off every disease known to man (and there are, sadly, new ones invented — by fear and greed — every day). Pharma companies are making out like bandits, literally. But their motives are being uncovered by intelligent individuals who dare to question “authority.”